Your blogging is diluting my conversation

May 1st 2008
View Comments
respond
trackback


 

No, don’t worry, this post is not about blogging per se, and you won’t find a tedious Slideshare slideshow below pointing out the obvious or the ubiquitous YouTube video by Commoncraft. Blogs have an enormous potential for schools, but that is not what this post is about. This ground has already been well trodden.

This post, as all my posts, has two primary purposes: to help me understand and to make me reflect. The fact that you are kindly and patiently reading what goes on inside my head serves another selfish purpose: you might do some reflection of your own and you might share it with me.

I am immensely grateful to everyone who reads my blog and, particularly, to those who have interacted with me through it by pointing out what a fool I am sometimes or what a good idea that other thing was. Mostly the former, I have to admit.

This is precisely what is so good about Web 2.0: the reflection, the sharing, the collaboration and, most importantly, the learning.

This is why I find it so disheartening that some bloggers, who have spent a huge amount of time blogging about blogging and how beneficial to us all it is, suddenly start talking about there being too many bloggers diluting the conversation, or too many bloggers who fad on the latest gadget and don’t really care about the pedagogy behind it.

I, for one, don’t quote straight out of my doctoral thesis when writing a post. I don’t set out to teach, I set out to learn from the experience of writing about a topic and from you. 

I am also capable of reaching my own conclusions about pedagogy and will not begrudge someone the fact that they blogged about the newest web gadget and did not write a dissertation about its pedagogical value: I am just happy that that person was willing to share that information with me, I can then decide whether it actually is of any use to me, without pretentiously criticising the format in which the information was delivered.

In addition, I don’t think that a blog should be used as a platform to spew out quasi-intelligent rhetorical questions or magniloquent platitudes, such as the above mentioned you’re diluting my conversation, we need revolution, not evolution or, my favourite, if you don’t understand what I am talking about, you’re missing the point.

After all, we can all ask questions, can’t we? It’s just that I am rather more interested in the answers. 

As far as blogging and Web 2.0 are concerned, my philosophy remains unchanged: cuantos más, mejor – the more, the merrier. Don’t you think?

Related Posts with Thumbnails

This post is tagged , ,

  • Guest
    Doug,

    Glad I can count on your forgiveness.

    By the way, do you know what you call a man with a spade on his head? ;)
  • OK, you're forgiven Hose-B... ;-)

    I know what you mean about simply un-following or unsubscribing from their Twitter feeds/blogs, but when it's so many it becomes disconcerting.

    Vive la Différence! (so long as it's pedagogically-sound)
  • Guest
    Dear Doug,

    It was certainly not my intention to have a dig, little or otherwise, at you personally. I was simply responding to the views I had read in some blog posts and, when I read yours, I simply reacted. Perhaps I did not express myself appropriately (after all English is not my mother tongue!) but it was not meant to be a serious comment, rather a tongue-in-cheek one.

    You have to understand Doug that, if I didn't give a monkeys, I wouldn't have bothered to comment on your blog, which I read regularly by the way.

    What I meant to say was that I don't disagree with the thrust of what you said, I actually may agree that some people are in on it for the ride, I just don't judge those people. If I think it appropriate, I will simply un-subscribe from their feeds or un-follow them in Twitter, but without making a big fuss about it or letting everyone know.

    Hope that clarifies my opinion and thank you so much for commenting on this post Doug.

    José
  • Can't help but thinking you're having a little dig at me here, José, after your comment on this blog post of mine...

    It's impossible not to agree with what you've written above; I'm certainly not trying to dictate what people write on what are, after all, their own blogs. Rather, I'm more concerned with people 'getting' the pedagogical goal of all this. You, José, are someone who 'gets' it. You're using these tools to effect changes in your organization - as attested to by what you say in the EdTechRoundup meetings.

    But there are others who use blogs, Twitter, and other Web 2.0 tools to 'stay in the crowd' or to just pass on, unthinkingly, a 'cool tool' they've come across. This isn't the way to effect change. This is the way to perpetuate and prop-up using new technology an outdated system.

    I hope you agree. :-)
  • Hey Jose, not too much more to add to the comments above, apart from to wholeheartedly agree with your sentiments. At times it's very easy to get distracted by your own perspectives on things and lose track of what's actually important in education - helping each other to teach better and thus help the pupils learn better. As such, in many ways, the more voices, the better. And if something doesn't work for you or you don't agree with it, don't read it - but why tell that person that they're not allowed to write as these people seem to at times?!

    Keep up the great work, buddy
  • So very true Jose - wise words indeed. (I always write that when I agree with something!)
  • Well put Jose.
    If you don't find something useful - don't read it. That doesn't mean it is not useful to other people, or to the person that wrote it. I don't look at it as diluting the conversation but as more books in the library that I can choose from.
    As always, thanks for your thoughts.
  • This is so well put Jose. You have summed up precisely the thoughts I have been having about the edublogosphere for some time. There are some very well educated and thoughtful, yet petty people out there whom seem to feel that blogging is, must be and for ever shall be a domain for them to expomd for all to listen to them.
    I had never written anything in the public domain until 2 years ago and I just like doing it. Sometimes it's rubbish sometimes it may be meaningful, but to be quite honest I am doing it for myself and those who want to read do so.
    Nice post.
  • Points all very well made - it is most certainly the more the merrier. The range of ideas and suggestions is the attraction for me - it is always good to hear what fellow teachers are up to in their classrooms.
blog comments powered by Disqus




Featured Posts



Popular Posts



Interactive Whiteboard Tutorials




Monthly Archives


Categories

Flickr

IMG_1921 IMG_1904 IMG_1883 IMG_1877 IMG_1876 IMG_1845 IMG_1841 IMG_1836 IMG_1833 IMG_1831 IMG_1830 IMG_1826

Twitter

Recent Visitors